Tuesday, February 12, 2013

Course assignment – Reflection 2

In the first section of this week’s reading discussed everyday settings and family activities that involve science. Pointing out an important fact that learning takes place in multiple settings. This is especially important in science learning that, I personally feel, needs to be experienced more than taught. Another important aspect of the beginning of this section is a fact that science learning can be a family experience. Going back to my last blog I remember this being true in my life. I feel that my family gave me a legacy in the love of science. But it also commented about how science can be experienced in multiple settings with young and old alike. One of the things that I got out of this first part was in the section titled, Setting For Everyday Learning, pointed out some facts I never thought about how family learning activities involving science can be everyday activities such as fishing, gardening are great to other activities. These activities often can involve spontaneous informal science experiences. Also I found interesting the section of chapter 4 were stranded 4, reflecting on science, where Sandoval was quoted in regards to the four aspects of science that students have difficulty in understanding. It discusses how they believe that science is constructed by people rather than its people interpreting evidence. Students often don’t see science as it dynamic and changing subject that often what is believed to be true one day can be disproved the next. Also students think of science is being experiments without understanding all of the different methodology involved in science. And finally the last concept is it many students see hypothesis, theory, and law being sequenced in this order. The next chapter titled, Science Learning in Designed Settings, it’s much closer to home in regards to our project. I have decided to do my project at the Kay Bailey Hutchinson desalinization plant off of Montana. I’m in the process in developing a combination of a tour of the plant with explanation of the procedure as well as introducing information in regards to water conservation. This section gave me important things to think about in developing my project. The very end of the section on Strand one talks about comfort which I never thought about having an effect on learning in an informal environment which really makes sense because it’s important informal environment as well. In discussing Strand 3 in this chapter made me think of the importance of creating an interactive educational experience as well as understanding the importance of meaning – making which is making the experience personal to the participant. Participants are involved in doing and saying, questioning and explaining making sense of the natural world. When it came to Strand 5 I found interesting the concept of social interaction and learning multigenerational groups because I believe it builds strong bonds and increase the learning experience for all generations. The last chapter we covered is titled, Programs for Young and Old, which discusses the difference between formal and out of class science learning programs. In this discussion and told about two different points of view of researchers in regards to the program goals and outcomes. Where one group is more concerned with development of positive attitude, skills and social relationships while the others are more concerned with the academic outcome but I personally feel both have equal importance.

6 comments:

  1. Cameron,

    I agree with your reflection. In particular I agree that students mostly perceive science as difficult because they do not see science as a "dynamic" experience and they fail to understand science is mostly the human interpretation of the natural world. However, as Bell, Lewestein, Shouser, & Feder (2009) explained on Strand 3 we need to engage and encourage learners in "questioning, explaining, and making sense of the natural and designed world" (Bell, Lewestein, Shouser, & Feder, p. 161, 2009). By allowing learners to experience hands-on activities they are able to discern science as a tangible and changing study, rather than a bunch of concepts they are required to learn for a test. I look forward to reading more about your project proposal.

    Karla Martinez.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great Reflection Cameron. I too attribute my family for my love of science and really, my love of learning in general. I was encouraged to explore and discover anything that interested me. My parents allowed me to join science clubs and participate in science fairs with their full support. In addition, my father took advantage of the spontaneous learning described in the book. If we ever had questions he made it a point to help us search for and analyze the question in order to develop and answer--something that I will forever be grateful for. I do recognize that I was fortunate in this aspect and not all children may experience this encouragement. This is all the more reason to incorporate more informal science educational experiences in the general academic settings.

    Your project idea sounds great! I can't wait to see more information about it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cameron:
      It is indeed true that informal science learning is nontraditional and could actually be fun to do. I totally agree with you as you argue that learning “takes place in multiple settings and (as you say) is especially important in science learning that needs to be experienced more than taught” (Wilson, 2013).
      I do however want to emphasize that if a certain phenomenon or discrepant event is being experienced through tactile-kinesthetic experiential modalities, it is indeed being taught as well, albeit employing a different more hands-on approach to target and avenue of cognition.
      For example, the fact that one can take his/her son, daughter, niece or nephew fishing and talk about how the gills on a fish function (TEKS Objective 2), or take the opportunity to explain the processes involved in the metamorphosis which helps to explain the very ontogeny of the frog’s development from tadpole to adult frog (TEKS Objective 3) or take full advantage of utilizing all three of Newton’s Laws of Motion to explain how “bumper cars” operate and conserve momentum, and demonstrate all three of Newton’s Laws of Motion and why and how energy is conserved.
      Good Job!
      Ruben Estrada

      Delete
  3. I agree with my classmates in the sense that if our students dont feel like the subject is interesting and engaging that it is hard and they pretty much wont take the subject seriously most of the time doing the bare minimum to pass on by. This chapter was a good chapter since it gave specific ways in which science can be taugh and learned in a non traditional way. It is very learner centered and focused aroud their interest and curiosity.I agree with melissa having a little one of my own, I love it when he is curious and wants to find out how things work and why. He happens to love science and I love that I am able to help him learn and explore those thigs that he is curious about. I also make it a point to make science fun and engaging so my students are more open and willing to learn.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I loved your statement about how some science, "needs to be experienced more than taught." I would agree with that statement for most science. We really need to emphasize science as, not only a noun, but also a verb. You really seem to have encapsulated this chapter in your summary. It seems that your ideas that are coming from a place of experience and your statements, therefore, have the authority of your convictions.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Cameron,

    I do too like your statement "science needs to be experienced more than taught." I also like Danny's phrase "science is not only a noun but also a verb!" What a beautiful description about science. One of my objective for this course is also to design an educational experience for all of you. Through conducting an educational project, I hope you all will remember this experience and hold more projects on your own for your students in the future.

    Cameron, your project sounds very exciting! I am glad that you can also gain insights from these readings to help you develop your project! Great work! I look forward to hearing more about your project!

    ReplyDelete